Another 255 V8 Question- Headers & Exhaust Manifold Compatibility
Reply #9 –
Even IF you can find a 255 crank that doesn't need work. IMO, it's simply not worth it. All the work to find one, then make sure it's true and doesn't need worked over. Buy a good forged crank and start with that, that way you'll know your bottom end is stable. If I was going to go that route, it wouldn't be in a stock block anyway, so the comparison is baseless.
And your second statement is ass-backwards. The run of the mill windsor engines had cast cranks. Some of the hot ones though were forged, but typically, cranks from Ford were cast.
All but the cheapest aftermarket cranks are forged, that's why there is a demand for 'em, so people can build a stronger engine.
But, it's been proven time and time and time again, a modded stock-based crank will usually outlast a 5.0 block. Or at least when the block lets go, it won't be due to crank failure. That's why I wouldn't bother swapping a crank for less than 10 pounds of weight, and then needing a witch doctor to balance the new rotating assembly all over again, and having a time of it. I've got better things to do than find a 31 year old part to put in a H/C/I combo that won't gain any more power over the stock part, to only save 5-8 pounds. Now, if it added a bit of stroke to boot, I'd only sing praise.
In short, for the gain, it's too much work for me. Have at it if it's your cup of tea. LOL.